Friday, July 13, 2012

Beyond the tragedy of the commons

Endless Conversation

Express Staff Writer

Native Americans, as well as many other indigenous communities around the world, have been praised ceaselessly for their spiritual connections to Mother Nature. Oddly, they have not been as readily commended for their skills at managing natural resources.

Thanks to Elinor Ostrom, a scholar, activist and field researcher who won the Nobel Prize in economics in 2009, indigenous communities may one day be looked to for solutions to some of the world's most pressing ecological problems.

Ostrum died on June 12, followed only a short while later by her husband, Vincent, but not before their work together brought a new understanding of and appreciation for the many complex methods human beings have used for centuries to create sustainable resource-use practices.

Ostrum, a political scientist by training, criticized long-held assumptions that top-down control is preferable to letting fishermen, hunters and farmers manage what she termed "common pool resources." By contrast, she showed that corporations aimed at profit or government agencies without deep ties to the land often do more harm than good.

In a valley such as ours, where commonly shared natural resources are a vital part of the economy, Ostrum's ideas are well worth noting. Who should we look to when seeking ways to regulate the shared use of our environmental resources?

Elinor Ostrum criticized in particular "The Tragedy of the Commons," an essay written by ecologist Garrett Hardin, first published in the journal Science in 1968. The essay cited historical sources to claim that herders using a commonly held field would, if left to their own devices, overuse and ultimately deplete the shared resource. The essay has been cited for decades in arguments in support of the privatization of once commonly used property.

Ostrum conducted field research around the world that showed the reverse to be true. For example, she found Turkish fishermen who had been drawing up coastal fishing maps and agreed-upon regulations in cafes for generations, and families in New Mexico and Nepal that had successfully managed communal water resources for agriculture, without the help of outside agencies.

Ostrum found that a government-engineered solution to irrigation challenges in one community was far less successful than one developed by farmers themselves.

Ostrum pointed out that open-ocean fishermen pose the greatest threat to fish populations because they work without the social controls that are a part of local communities.

"Trust is at the center of how people solve dilemmas," she said in one of her many lectures available on the Internet.

Ostrum's work inspired further research that she hoped would one day find a multitude of solutions to the threat of global warming, rather than relying solely on government institutions and private enterprise to save the day.

"We need to build enough diversity to cope with the diversity of the world—allow a multi-tiered system at multiple scales [instead of] a top-down panacea that is predicted to cure everything and instead kills it," she said. "The presumption is that it always has to be the state, the big guy with the gun, that needs to tell us what to do."

Ostrum also challenged a trend in economics that focuses on mathematical formulas, rather than analyzing data gathered from real-world practices. Although her work was only slowly accepted by the academic community, she succeeded in helping to establish several interdisciplinary institutions that use collaborations with scholars across academia, including ecologists, computer scientists and psychologists.

In a New York Times article this month, Ostrum's work was lauded by Nancy Folbre, an economics professor at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst.

"She would go and actually talk to Indonesian fisherman, or Maine lobstermen, and ask, 'How did you come to establish this limit on the fish catch? How did you deal with the fact that people might try to get around it?'" Folbre wrote. "Every successive cohort of economists is trained to put greater emphasis on the arsenal of mathematical and econometric expertise. That was just not what her work was about."

About Comments

Comments with content that seeks to incite or inflame may be removed.

Comments that are in ALL CAPS may be removed.

Comments that are off-topic or that include profanity or personal attacks, libelous or other inappropriate material may be removed from the site. Entries that are unsigned or contain signatures by someone other than the actual author may be removed. We will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of use or any other policies governing this site. Use of this system denotes full acceptance of these conditions. Please review the full rules governing commentaries and discussions. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.

The comments below are from the readers of and in no way represent the views of Express Publishing, Inc.

You may flag individual comments. You may also report an inappropriate or offensive comment by clicking here.

Flagging Comments: Flagging a comment tells a site administrator that a comment is inappropriate. You can find the flag option by pointing the mouse over the comment and clicking the 'Flag' link.

Flagging a comment is only counted once per person, and you won't need to do it multiple times.

Proper Flagging Guidelines: Every site has a different commenting policy - be sure to review the policy for this site before flagging comments. In general these types of comments should be flagged:

  • Spam
  • Ones violating this site's commenting policy
  • Clearly unrelated
  • Personal attacks on others
Comments should not be flagged for:
  • Disagreeing with the content
  • Being in a dispute with the commenter

Popular Comment Threads

 Local Weather 
Search archives:

Copyright © 2020 Express Publishing Inc.   Terms of Use   Privacy Policy
All Rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of Express Publishing Inc. is prohibited. 

The Idaho Mountain Express is distributed free to residents and guests throughout the Sun Valley, Idaho resort area community. Subscribers to the Idaho Mountain Express will read these stories and others in this week's issue.