No disappearing
act
A federal
judge took away the U.S. Department of Energy’s magic wand this week.
The
department had planned to reclassify one million gallons of highly
radioactive nuclear waste to "incidental" waste. It looked
like an unprecedented disappearing act.
Reclassification
would allow the DOE to duck its agreement with Idaho to remove the waste
from the Idaho National Engineering and Environmental Laboratory to a
permanent storage facility. Instead, the DOE wants to enclose tanks of
radioactive sludge in cement and leave them stored 500 feet above the
Snake River Aquifer.
The
aquifer is a key source of water for southern Idaho. Its underground
waters eventually emerge near Twin Falls.
The DOE’s
magic didn’t work on a federal judge. The judge this week told the DOE
that it couldn’t just wave its magic wand and make highly radioactive
waste disappear by changing its name. The judge ordered the DOE to
defend its decision—or rescind the sleight of hand.
Good for
the judge. Disappearing acts are best left to professional magicians—not
to government agencies who are supposed to be in the business of
protecting the public.