Shell game
A bill introduced
into the U.S. Senate to make recreation fees on public lands permanent
is a slap in the face to the people who supported and promoted the
controversial fees.
Senate Bill 1011,
introduced by Sens. Bob Graham, D-Fla., and Daniel Akaka, D-Hawii, is
full of surprises.
The bill would
allow up to 40 percent of the recreation fees collected on public land
to be used agency-wide by the U.S. Forest Service, National Park
Service, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and Bureau of Land Management.
In other words,
fees paid on the Sawtooth National Forest could be spent on forest
projects in other states or for general expenses on the national level.
That’s a far cry
from the way the fees were sold to the public in the Recreation Fee
Demonstration Program.
Time after time,
the Forest Service and Idaho’s senators and congressmen assured the
public that at least 80 percent of the fees would be spent at the site
where they are collected instead of going back to the U.S. Treasury.
They promised that the other 20 percent would be distributed among other
sites in the area.
That was then.
This is now. This bill shatters those assurances.
The bill also
omits the U.S. Forest Service from a prohibition on displacing regularly
budgeted funds with income derived from fees.
Forest officials
promised repeatedly that forest budgets would not be replaced by fees,
but supplemented by fees. The bill carries no such guarantee.
The bill unmasks
the Recreation Fee Demonstration Program and finally shows it for what
it is: a government shell game foisted on a gullible public.