Back to Home Page

Local Links
Sun Valley Guide
Hemingway in Sun Valley
Real Estate

Opinion Column
For the week of February 7 through 13, 2001

Shortages (usually) 
have a bracing effect 
on consumers

Commentary by PAT MURPHY


If California truly is the harbinger of trends for the rest of the country, then nearby states watching California’s electricity chaos and rolling blackouts have reason to fret.

Do other western states, such as Idaho, where demand for electricity is soaring with growth in industry and population, face bleak months ahead, as some pessimists forecast?

Since the end of World War II, public utilities—electric, telephone, water, gas— generally have underestimated growth in booming western states and been stretched to meet demand.

State regulatory commissions that are supposed to enforce "convenience and necessity" laws that require utilities to provide adequately for the public have a checkered record.

No matter.

My guess is that shortages have a bracing effect on American consumers, like a bucket of cold water to remind us that plenty has its limits and supply isn’t always there to meet our demands.

Our bountiful society has known severe shortages only a few times in several generations. Each time, we survived handsomely. But when times improved, we inevitably broke promises to be more sparing in consumption.

The Great Depression of the 1930s and World War II shortages of virtually everything ¾ clothing, food, appliances, gasoline, electricity ¾ forced a whole nation into austerity. But then good times returned when GIs returned home and industry rolled out every imaginable consumer goody.

Although a relatively minor inconvenience, the Arab oil embargo of the early 1970s spawned autos that gave more mileage per gallon. But gas-guzzlers quickly returned with times of plenty.

Now, the possibility of belt-tightening seems at hand again. Joblessness is rising, dark whispers of recession are on the lips of economists, electricity supplies are in doubt, the Middle East is in turmoil again.

So what if we have to shrink consumption. A diet of any sort is good.

#

In baseball, batters are out after three strikes. In criminal justice laws in some states, three convictions and it’s a life sentence.

Idaho’s Republican state party chairman, Trent Clark, is up to two strikes. At this rate, his mouth is bound to get him in trouble a third time.

Will Republicans who think better of their party finally dump Clark?

His first strike was when he trashed fellow Republican, Boise Mayor Brent Coles, for fulfilling obligations as outgoing president of the U.S. Conference of Mayors by presenting an award to outgoing President Clinton for helping cities.

His second strike was last week when he defended the Kootenai County Republican chairman under fire for an old drug arrest by stupidly using a metaphor about African Americans ¾ that it would be tough to find a black man in Washington, D.C. without a criminal history.

Despite his unzipped lip and utterly bizarre judgment for a man in his position, Clark so far seems safe in his job.

Idaho’s top Republicans obviously haven’t gotten the word that spiteful outbursts that symbolized the days of the unrestrained Newt Gingrich have been replaced by the "charm offensive" of George W. Bush.

 

Back to Front Page
Copyright © 2000 Express Publishing Inc. All Rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of Express Publishing Inc. is prohibited.