Back to Home Page

Local Links
Sun Valley Guide
Hemingway in Sun Valley
Real Estate

Editorials
For the week of November 15 through 21, 2000

Pluses of the national suspense


No coup d'etat, no riots in the streets, no declaration of martial law.

Instead, the delay in naming the new American president means fresh wisecracks for late-night comics, overtime pay for Florida vote canvassers, a windfall of work for lawyers and something new about which Americans can grumble.

But much serious good emerges from this suspense.

Not in modern political memory has the public been so riveted on its national affairs as a learning experience, and never before have so many opportunities come along to reform medieval election practices.

Forget tacky partisanship of Gore and Bush camps. Broader, more lasting issues affecting the precious American vote are at play.

The incomprehensibly muddled polling in Florida's Palm Beach County focuses attention on one of America's most indefensible scandals: ballots and counting procedures across the nation that befit another century.

The world's most advanced electronic society still uses paper-punch ballots that confuse voters and can't be accurately read because of paper "chads" plugging holes after being punched.

Hundreds of other counties select a crazy-quilt of voting methods, from an advanced electronic touch pad keeping pace with the times to aging machines and ballots designed more than a half century ago.

Heretical as it may be to states-righters, why not a national standard for elections, the most fundamental linchpin of U.S. democracy.

States-righters don't complain of national standards for auto tires, for airline safety, for pharmaceuticals, for healthfulness of foods, for banking rules, for voting rights of all citizens, and hundreds of other services and goods touching American lives.

And then there's the quadrennial eruption of complaints about staggered poll closings and the impact of early TV predictions on votes in the western states. Is the solution a new formula of voting hours, as well as more convenient polling places where people conduct daily business--in shopping malls, at banks, in supermarkets--to increase participation and ensure access? Perhaps.

Finally, the matter of the Electoral College: With the presidency hanging on the outcome of who receives Florida's 25 electoral votes, a renewed chant to abolish the Electoral College and rely solely on the popular vote is filling the air.

Strong grounds exist for repealing Article II, Section 1 of the U.S. Constitution—better communications, a literate populace, and at least a century of experience that shows electing leaders by popular vote works in the modern age.

But scholars on both sides of the question make compelling arguments that must be thoroughly debated before hastily tinkering with the nation's most durable and efficient document because of a rare, historic stalemate.

If the nation works out the matters raised by this historic presidential race, it will be all the better for it.

 

Back to Front Page
Copyright 2000 Express Publishing Inc. All Rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of Express Publishing Inc. is prohibited.